Question
If , , and , find .
(NCERT Class 12, Exercise 13.1)
Solution — Step by Step
This reads: “the probability of given that has occurred.”
If we know event has happened, the probability that also happened is .
Notice that . This means knowing occurred actually decreases the chance of — the events are negatively correlated.
Why This Works
Conditional probability restricts the sample space. When we know has occurred, the entire universe shrinks to just . The only part of that matters is the part that overlaps with — which is . The ratio gives us the proportion of that also belongs to .
Think of it with a Venn diagram: is your new “whole world,” and is the portion of that world where is true.
Alternative Method — Check independence and find P(B|A) too
We can also verify: are and independent?
For independence, we need .
But . So and are not independent.
Also, .
Note: in general — this is a common source of confusion.
The title mentions Bayes’ theorem, but for this direct calculation, the simple conditional probability formula suffices. Bayes’ theorem is useful when is not directly given and you need to compute it from and : .
Common Mistake
The biggest conceptual error: confusing with . Students write instead of dividing by . Remember — the event after the bar () goes in the denominator. “Given ” means is the condition, so is what you divide by. Writing it wrong gives — a different answer that looks equally reasonable.