Question
What factors affect the speed of sound in air? Why does pressure NOT affect the speed of sound, even though air is a compressible medium?
This is a classic NCERT Class 11 question that also shows up regularly in JEE Main as a concept-based MCQ.
Solution — Step by Step
Newton derived the speed of sound in a gas as:
where is the bulk modulus (elasticity) and is the density. This is the master formula — everything else follows from it.
For an ideal gas, pressure and density are related by , which gives (where is molar mass).
When pressure increases, increases by the same factor (since for adiabatic conditions), and so does . The ratio stays constant — pressure cancels out completely.
Substituting and :
Since , , and are constants for a given gas, we get:
Temperature here is in Kelvin — never Celsius.
Water vapour ( g/mol) is lighter than dry air ( g/mol). When humidity increases, the effective molar mass of the air mixture drops.
From , a smaller means a larger . So sound travels faster in humid air than in dry air.
Why This Works
The speed of a mechanical wave depends on the restoring force (elasticity) and the inertia (density) of the medium. Higher elasticity → faster wave. Higher density → slower wave.
When we increase pressure at constant temperature, yes, the air becomes “stiffer” (higher ). But it also packs more molecules into the same space (higher ). These two effects exactly cancel each other — a beautiful symmetry of ideal gases.
Temperature breaks this symmetry. Heating air at constant pressure increases because the molecules move faster and the medium transmits the disturbance more quickly, while the density change is less significant in the dependence.
Alternative Method
You can arrive at using dimensional reasoning combined with kinetic theory.
The RMS speed of gas molecules is . Since the speed of sound is essentially the speed at which a pressure disturbance propagates through molecular collisions, it must be proportional to . Hence .
This isn’t a derivation, but it’s a great way to quickly recall the temperature dependence in an exam when you’ve forgotten the exact formula.
Effect of Temperature: Numerical Form
where m/s at 0°C (273 K).
For small changes, there’s an approximation used in NCERT:
where is temperature in °C. At 20°C, m/s.
Common Mistake
Using Celsius instead of Kelvin in the ratio.
Students write and then plug in directly instead of K. If a question asks “by what factor does speed change when temperature doubles from 27°C to 54°C?”, the correct answer uses K and K — not 27 and 54. Doubling the Celsius value does NOT double the Kelvin temperature.
The ratio comes out to , a 4% increase — not .
Quick recall for JEE MCQs: The four factors and their effects in one line — Temperature ↑ (speed ↑), Pressure (no effect), Humidity ↑ (speed ↑ slightly), Molar mass ↑ (speed ↓). Pressure is the classic trap option.