Current Electricity: Real-World Scenarios (6)

hard 2 min read

Question

A household geyser is rated 20002000 W at 220220 V. Due to a voltage fluctuation in a Mumbai apartment, the supply drops to 200200 V. Find (a) the resistance of the heating element (assumed constant), (b) the actual power consumed at 200 V, and (c) the percentage drop in the heating rate. This is a JEE Advanced 2023 style question.

Solution — Step by Step

From P=V2/RP = V^2/R at the rated voltage:

R=V2P=22022000=484002000=24.2 ΩR = \frac{V^2}{P} = \frac{220^2}{2000} = \frac{48400}{2000} = 24.2 \text{ Ω}

The resistance of the nichrome element doesn’t change appreciably with this voltage drop. So:

P=V2R=200224.2=4000024.21653 WP' = \frac{V'^2}{R} = \frac{200^2}{24.2} = \frac{40000}{24.2} \approx 1653 \text{ W}

ΔP%=PPP×100=200016532000×10017.4%\Delta P\% = \frac{P - P'}{P} \times 100 = \frac{2000 - 1653}{2000} \times 100 \approx 17.4\%

R=24.2R = 24.2 Ω, P1653P' \approx 1653 W, percentage drop 17.4\approx 17.4%.

Why This Works

For a fixed-resistance device like a geyser or bulb, power scales as V2V^2. A small drop in voltage causes a much larger drop in heating rate. A 9% voltage drop (220200220 \to 200) gives a 17% power drop — almost double the percentage.

This is why your geyser feels slow during peak hours when voltage sags, and why bulbs visibly dim. The V2V^2 dependence amplifies every voltage variation.

Alternative Method

Use the ratio shortcut directly:

PP=(VV)2=(200220)2=(1011)2=100121\frac{P'}{P} = \left(\frac{V'}{V}\right)^2 = \left(\frac{200}{220}\right)^2 = \left(\frac{10}{11}\right)^2 = \frac{100}{121}

P=2000×1001211653 WP' = 2000 \times \frac{100}{121} \approx 1653 \text{ W}

This skips computing RR entirely — useful in MCQs where time matters.

A frequent trap: students assume power drops linearly with voltage. Wrong. For a fixed resistor, PV2P \propto V^2, so a 10% voltage drop is roughly a 20% power drop.

For appliances rated V0,P0V_0, P_0 operated at VV, the actual power is P=P0(V/V0)2P = P_0 (V/V_0)^2. Memorise this — saves 30 seconds in JEE Main.

Want to master this topic?

Read the complete guide with more examples and exam tips.

Go to full topic guide →

Try These Next