Question
Evaluate tan−1(1)+tan−1(2)+tan−1(3) and prove that it equals π.
A CBSE 12 board favourite — looks short but trips students on the principal-value sign.
Solution — Step by Step
tan−1A+tan−1B=tan−1(1−ABA+B)+nπ
where n depends on signs. For A=1,B=2: 1−AB=1−2=−1<0 and both A,B>0, so we add π.
tan−11+tan−12=tan−1((1+2)/(−1))+π=tan−1(−3)+π.
tan−1(−3)+π+tan−1(3)=π+(tan−1(−3)+tan−1(3)).
Since tan−1 is odd, tan−1(−3)+tan−1(3)=0.
Sum = π+0=π. Proved.
Final answer: tan−11+tan−12+tan−13=π.
Why This Works
The principal value of tan−1 lies in (−π/2,π/2). When the argument-formula gives a value outside this range, we adjust by ±π to land in the right branch.
For A,B>0 and AB>1, the sum exceeds π/2 (since both individual angles exceed π/4), so the formula needs a +π correction. This is the rule students forget.
Alternative Method
Geometric proof. Place a 1×1, 1×2, and 1×3 right triangle in a row. The three angles at the base sum to a straight angle (i.e., π). This visual proof is part of CBSE textbooks.
CBSE 2019 boards asked exactly this question. The trick to score full marks: explicitly justify the +π correction by checking the sign of 1−AB. Skipping that costs 1 mark.
Common Mistake
Naively writing tan−11+tan−12=tan−1(−3) without the +π correction. That gives a sum of tan−1(−3)+tan−13=0, which is clearly wrong (each individual term was positive).