Question
Compare the structures of , , and . Predict the shape, hybridisation, and approximate bond angles for each. Explain the trend.
Solution — Step by Step
Cl has 7 valence . Three are bonded to F, leaving 2 lone pairs. Total electron pairs: .
Shape: T-shaped (trigonal bipyramidal with two equatorial lone pairs). Bond angles slightly less than (around ) because lone pairs squeeze bonds.
Br has 7 valence . Five bonded to F, one lone pair remains. Total pairs: .
Shape: square pyramidal (octahedral with one position occupied by lone pair). Bond angles close to but less than .
I has 7 valence . Seven bonded to F, no lone pairs. Total pairs: .
Shape: pentagonal bipyramidal. Bond angles: equatorial , axial-equatorial .
As we move down Group 17 (Cl Br I), atomic size and number of available orbitals increase. Larger atoms accommodate more bonded atoms around them, expanding the octet further. This is why exists while does not.
| Molecule | Hybridisation | Shape | Bond angle |
|---|---|---|---|
| T-shaped | |||
| Square pyramidal | |||
| Pentagonal bipyramidal |
Why This Works
VSEPR + steric number determines geometry from electron pair count. Lone pairs occupy more space than bonding pairs, so they preferentially go to positions where they minimise repulsion (equatorial in trigonal bipyramidal, opposite-axial in octahedral).
The trend down the group reflects increasing ability to expand the valence shell using orbitals.
Alternative Method
Direct steric-number count: bonded atoms lone pairs. Then read off shape from a VSEPR table. No need to derive from scratch each time.
Common Mistake
Predicting trigonal planar for because it has 3 F atoms. VSEPR includes lone pairs. The two lone pairs on Cl distort the geometry from trigonal planar to T-shaped.