Question
Predict the major product when -bromobutane reacts with alcoholic KOH. Compare with the product of aqueous KOH. Explain the mechanism difference.
Solution — Step by Step
-bromobutane: — a secondary alkyl halide.
- Alcoholic KOH → strong base, weak nucleophile (alcohol solvates K⁺ better than OH⁻) → favours elimination (E2).
- Aqueous KOH → strong nucleophile (water solvates K⁺ less strongly, OH⁻ acts free) → favours substitution (S2).
E2 removes a -hydrogen and the leaving group () simultaneously, forming a C=C double bond. There are two possible -positions:
- Remove H from (left side): (-butene)
- Remove H from (right side): (-butene)
Zaitsev’s rule: the more substituted alkene is the major product. -butene has the double bond between two carbons each bearing alkyl group → more substituted.
Major product: -butene (mainly trans by stability).
S2: OH⁻ attacks the carbon bearing Br from the back side, displacing Br⁻ in one concerted step.
Major product: -butanol, , with inversion of configuration at the chiral carbon.
Why This Works
The solvent and base/nucleophile choice steers the reaction. In alcoholic KOH, the alcohol partially hydrogen-bonds with OH⁻, weakening its nucleophilic strength. The base abstracts a -H instead, leading to elimination.
In aqueous KOH, OH⁻ is well-solvated yet behaves as a strong nucleophile. The S2 transition state benefits from a free OH⁻.
For secondary substrates like -bromobutane, both E2 and S2 are kinetically accessible — the solvent decides.
Alternative Method
Use the rule of thumb: alcoholic = alkene (elimination), aqueous = alcohol (substitution). Mnemonic for board exams.
Common Mistake
Predicting -butene as the major product — that’s the Hofmann product (less substituted alkene), favoured only in special cases (bulky bases like -BuOK, or quaternary ammonium hydroxides). With KOH/ethanol, expect Zaitsev: -butene wins.
Forgetting that S2 inverts configuration. If -bromobutane is used as -enantiomer, the product is --butanol — important when stereochemistry is asked.
JEE Main 2023 Shift 2 asked: “Major product of -chlorobutane + alc. KOH”. Answer: -butene. Same pattern.